Understanding Hydroponics · Chapter 9 · Paper 5
Artificial Lighting Technologies and Light Delivery in Controlled Environment Horticulture
Supporting research for Light, Energy and Photosynthesis.
Research summary
Controlled environment agriculture (CEA) and hydroponic production systems depend on artificial lighting to supplement or replace solar radiation, yet the utility of a given fixture cannot be assessed from photon output alone. The technology family selected determines spectral composition, photon efficacy, thermal load, and the degree of controllability available to the operator. Fixture geometry, optics, and mounting position govern how photons are distributed through the canopy volume and whether the delivered light environment matches crop demand. This paper synthesises peer-reviewed evidence to compare the major horticultural artificial-lighting technology families, with emphasis on high-pressure sodium discharge lamps and light-emitting diode systems as the dominant commercial options. The analysis covers operating characteristics relevant to crop use, scientifically meaningful performance comparisons, the role of fixture geometry and inter-lighting placement in canopy light distribution, controllability and dimming as determinants of practical flexibility, and the thermal differences that constrain mounting options and climate interaction. The distinction between supplemental lighting in greenhouse settings, where solar radiation provides the baseline photon environment, and sole-source artificial lighting in fully enclosed systems is maintained throughout, because the criteria for technology selection differ substantially between these two production paradigms. The evidence indicates that LED technology offers advantages in photon efficacy, spectral flexibility, thermal profile, and dimming range, while inter-lighting geometry provides measurable agronomic benefits in tall-vine crops with deep canopies.
Original research sources
- Darren Chi Jin Neo and Maxine Min Xin Ong and Yeong Yuh Lee and Ee Jin Teo and Qunya Ong and Hendrix Tanoto and Jianwei Xu and Kian Soo Ong and Vignesh Suresh (2022) Shaping and Tuning Lighting Conditions in Controlled Environment Agriculture: A Review
- Jacob A. Nelson and Bruce Bugbee (2014) Economic Analysis of Greenhouse Lighting: Light Emitting Diodes vs.
- Fasil Tadesse Tewolde and Kouta Shiina and Toru Maruo and Michiko Takagaki and Toyoki Kozai and Wataru Yamori (2018) Supplemental LED inter-lighting compensates for a shortage of light for plant growth and yield under the lack of sunshine